Patient Conversations
How to Respond to Patients Bringing Online Medical Advice
How to respond to patients bringing online medical advice: empathetic scripts, source appraisal, scope limits, documentation, and trusted resources.
When a patient brings online medical advice to a visit, ask what they found and why it caught their attention, then review it against their own history, medications, and labs before you agree, adjust, or decline. Studies of internet-informed patients suggest that talking it through can strengthen the relationship. Guiding the patient to use what they found alongside clinical expertise is what one review calls a participative approach. The hard part is time, since reviewing an outside claim properly inside a visit is a known pressure point. This guide covers how to open the conversation, how to sort what applies, and how to close with a plan the patient understands.
Updated October 2026. Written by Andrew Le, MD. Sources are listed at the end.
Why the conversation matters
A systematic review of 18 studies looked at how internet health information seeking affects the patient and clinician relationship (Tan and Goonawardene, 2017). Its main finding was that this kind of searching can improve the relationship, depending on whether the patient discusses the information with the physician and on their prior relationship (Tan and Goonawardene, 2017).
A later review of 22 studies asked physicians how they handle internet-informed patients (Lu and Schulz, 2024). It found two strategies. The participative approach guides patients to use internet information together with the physician's expertise, and the defensive approach discourages patients from searching at all (Lu and Schulz, 2024). The same review listed the pressures physicians report, including time pressure, a lack of structured training, and uncertainty about which trustworthy sites to recommend (Lu and Schulz, 2024).
Open with a question
In a study of patients taking supplements, the most commonly raised reason for disclosure was simply that the provider asked (Guzman et al., 2019). A plain opener works: "What have you been reading or hearing about this?" Then ask what they hope will change if they follow it.
Validate the concern before the content
Acknowledge the worry that sent the patient searching before you weigh any claim. A review of patient-centered communication names eliciting the patient's agenda with open-ended questions, letting the patient finish without interruption, and focused active listening as basic skills (Hashim, 2017). The same review describes expressing empathy by naming the feeling and by communicating understanding, respect, and support (Hashim, 2017).
Those openings are often missed: in 20 recorded lung cancer consultations, clinicians responded with empathy to 39 of 384 empathic opportunities, about 10% (Morse et al., 2008). A short reflection is enough to catch one:
- "That sounds worrying. Which part of it stayed with you most?"
- "It makes sense to look for answers when something has dragged on this long."
- "Thanks for bringing it in. Looking at it together is a good use of the visit."
Scripted responses to specific online claims
Interviews with cancer clinicians identified four ways they respond to online misinformation: work to understand it, correct it through education, advise about future online searches, and preserve the clinician and patient relationship (Bylund et al., 2023). A follow-up study recorded 17 cancer clinicians answering a standardized patient who asked three questions based on treatment misinformation (Mullis et al., 2024). The authors present those four responses as the Misinformation Response Model (Mullis et al., 2024).
The scripts below follow the same four moves. Give the correction in small pieces, since a review of communication skills recommends repeated cycles of the ask, tell, ask approach for medical information (Hashim, 2017). Adjust the wording to the patient and to the claim.
A post says a supplement will fix their fatigue.
- Understand: "What did the post promise, and who was selling the product?"
- Correct: "Here is what studies show for tiredness like yours, and here is how this product could interact with your current medicines."
- Future searches: "When a page sells the product it praises, check the claim on an independent site that sells nothing." NCCIH gives the same advice for any site that sells products (NCCIH).
- Relationship: "Bring the next one in too. It is worth a look."
A video warns that a prescribed medicine is dangerous.
- Understand: "What did the video say would happen? Have you noticed any of that yourself?"
- Correct: "These are the known side effects, and this is how often they appeared in the studies."
- Future searches: "Look for a date on the page." NCCIH warns that outdated medical information can mislead or even put people at risk (NCCIH).
- Relationship: "If you want to stop or change it, call first so any change is planned and safe."
A search result points to a test that was never ordered.
- Understand: "What were you hoping the test would show?"
- Correct: "This is what the test can tell about your situation, and this is what it would miss."
- Future searches: "Check whether the site names the research behind its claims." NCCIH says a site should describe the evidence its material is based on (NCCIH).
- Relationship: "If the test still matters to you after this, the choice can be made together."
A testimonial says a protocol cured someone with the same complaint.
- Understand: "What about that story sounded like yours?"
- Correct: "A single story is a starting point. Here is what studies of many people found."
- Future searches: NCCIH reminds readers that testimonials, anecdotes, unsupported claims, and opinions differ from objective, evidence-based information (NCCIH).
- Relationship: "Keep sending these. Each one is a chance to look at the evidence side by side."
Set boundaries on scope and liability
Some online advice asks for something outside safe care for this patient, such as a prescription or a test that does not fit the case. A study of standardized patient visits examined how primary care clinicians declined requests for an antidepressant prescription (Paterniti et al., 2010). In 53 of 84 visits, the clinicians used at least one of three strategies built on the patient perspective: exploring the context of the request, referring to a mental health professional, and offering an alternative explanation for the complaint (Paterniti et al., 2010). The standardized patients rated their visits as significantly more satisfying when the refusal relied on those approaches (Paterniti et al., 2010). The authors suggest that strategies for saying no can communicate appropriate care plans, reduce medically inappropriate services, and protect the relationship (Paterniti et al., 2010).
The same three moves carry over to online advice. Ask what sits behind the request, offer a referral when the question belongs to another specialty, and propose an option that fits the case.
On liability, start with the disclosure standard. Informed consent law has moved toward a materiality or patient viewpoint standard (ACOG Committee Opinion No. 306, 2004). Under it, a physician must share the risks, benefits, and alternatives that a reasonable person in the patient's position would want to know (ACOG Committee Opinion No. 306, 2004). This page is general information. For questions about your own liability, ask your malpractice carrier or legal counsel.
Teach the patient to check a source
A Cochrane review lists inadequate skills to search, evaluate, and use online health information among the barriers consumers face (Car et al., 2011). It found low quality evidence that training may improve some online health literacy outcomes in certain populations (Car et al., 2011). In its one randomized trial, outcomes that improved included health information evaluation skills and how often participants discussed online information with a health provider (Car et al., 2011).
A short set of questions from NCCIH, part of the National Institutes of Health, gives the patient something to carry into the next search.
- Who runs and pays for the site? A reliable health site should make it easy to learn who is responsible for it (NCCIH).
- Did experts review it? Confidence in a page goes up when health experts reviewed it (NCCIH).
- Where did the information come from? Sites that collect material from elsewhere should identify those sources (NCCIH).
- Is it current? Responsible sites review and update much of their content on a regular basis (NCCIH).
- Is advice set apart from evidence? Opinions and advice should be clearly separated from information based on research results (NCCIH).
Sort what applies to this patient
Go through the advice one item at a time and check it against what you know about this person: their conditions, current medications, allergies, recent labs, and goals. Each item usually lands in one of three groups.
- It fits their case and can be part of the plan.
- It might fit, and you need more information first.
- It does not fit their case, and you can say why.
One researcher definition is useful here. Health misinformation has been defined as a health-related claim that is based on anecdotal evidence, false, or misleading owing to the lack of existing scientific knowledge (Suarez-Lledo and Alvarez-Galvez, 2021). Asking which of those applies to each item keeps the review specific.
Document the conversation
Write a brief note so the next visit can pick up where this one ended. When a patient declines a recommendation after this kind of discussion, ACOG calls documentation of the informed refusal process essential (ACOG Committee Opinion No. 306, 2004). Notes can carry the patient's side of the visit as well. One study reviewed 477 notes for 311 patients at four medical centers (Butler et al., 2022). Patient goals and the patient's own voice were among the concepts of patient-centered care documented most often (Butler et al., 2022).
A useful note for an online claim covers:
- the source in question (site, post, video, or chatbot) and the concern behind it
- the parts that apply, the parts that need more data, and the parts set aside, each with its reason
- any reading or resources you suggested
- the plan, the patient's choice, and when you will follow up
Point the patient to trusted resources
Ending with a named source turns advice about future searches into something the patient can use at home. For general health topics, NCCIH suggests starting with organized collections of high-quality resources (NCCIH). One of those is MedlinePlus, sponsored by the National Library of Medicine (NCCIH). For dietary supplements, NCCIH points readers to the NIH Office of Dietary Supplements (NCCIH). A referral to a specialist belongs on the same list when the question sits outside your scope.
Close with a plan the patient can follow
A widely cited model of shared decision making has three steps: introducing choice, describing options, and helping patients explore preferences and make decisions (Elwyn et al., 2012). For outside research, that means naming the decision, laying out what you would keep, change, or set aside, and asking what matters most to the patient before you agree on next steps. For the harder version of this conversation, see how to disagree and keep their trust.
Where HANS fits
HANS keeps each answer tied to the chart you built for that patient, drawing on their conditions, medications, allergies, labs, and documents at the moment you ask. Its research feature is meant for weighing an outside recommendation against the case and citing sources you can walk the patient through. You guide the work and review what HANS drafts. Walk through the workflow on how HANS works.
Frequently asked questions
How should clinicians respond to patients bringing online medical advice?
Clinicians can respond to patients bringing online medical advice by using a nonjudgmental, collaborative approach. Listen empathetically to understand their emotional state and what they hope to achieve.
What should a clinician consider before correcting the claim?
Consider the patient's fears, background, and why the source resonated with them.
What does a complete response to online medical advice cover?
Validating patient concerns and building rapport. Scripting empathetic responses to specific online claims. Distinguishing between credible sources and misinformation. Educating patients on critical appraisal of digital health information. Setting boundaries on scope of practice and liability. Documenting the discussion in the medical record. Referring to trusted resources when appropriate.
Related guides
Sources
- Internet Health Information Seeking and the Patient-Physician Relationship: A Systematic Review. J Med Internet Res. 2017. PubMed 28104579
- Physician Perspectives on Internet-Informed Patients: Systematic Review. J Med Internet Res. 2024. PubMed 38842920
- Factors Related to Disclosure and Nondisclosure of Dietary Supplements in Primary Care, Integrative Medicine, and Naturopathic Medicine. J Fam Med Dis Prev. 2019. PubMed 32051918
- Patient-Centered Communication: Basic Skills. Am Fam Physician. 2017. PubMed 28075109
- Missed opportunities for interval empathy in lung cancer communication. Arch Intern Med. 2008. PubMed 18809811
- Clinician Communication With Patients About Cancer Misinformation: A Qualitative Study. JCO Oncol Pract. 2023. PubMed 36626708
- Clinician-patient communication about cancer treatment misinformation: The Misinformation Response Model. PEC Innov. 2024. PubMed 39101055
- Getting to "no": strategies primary care physicians use to deny patient requests. Arch Intern Med. 2010. PubMed 20177043
- ACOG Committee Opinion No. 306. Informed refusal. Obstet Gynecol. 2004. PubMed 15572515
- Interventions for enhancing consumers' online health literacy. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2011. PubMed 21678364
- Prevalence of Health Misinformation on Social Media: Systematic Review. J Med Internet Res. 2021. PubMed 33470931
- Clinician documentation of patient centered care in the electronic health record. BMC Med Inform Decis Mak. 2022. PubMed 35279157
- Shared decision making: a model for clinical practice. J Gen Intern Med. 2012. PubMed 22618581
- Know the Science: Finding Health Information Online. National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health. NCCIH module
- How HANS works
- HANS pricing
Author
Written by Andrew Le, MD. Andrew Le, MD is the founder and CEO of HANS.
Next step
See how HANS works on a real case, then compare HANS plans.
